Showing posts with label Communications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Communications. Show all posts

Wednesday, 15 February 2012

Can Citizen Journalism enliven a distracted, de-professionalised media?

Picture at left from here.

In Australia, Murdoch and Fairfax are making their way to some form of transition from the print to digital age with more or less success, and more or less revenue. In Britain, The Guardian makes no bones about what it is about. It's policy is definitely digital. As part of its digital publishing, The Guardian is mixing its stable of traditional journalists with enthusiastic laypeople.  


I am out of love with large sections of the media - print or otherwise - these days.  My trust is given to only a handful of very senior (yes, you can read very old into that!) journalists.

Once upon a long ago, journalism was much like learning a trade.  A university degree was not required.  Some, like my cousin, graduated from being a linotype operator writing about motorbikes for his favourite magazine to real-life journalism and crime reporting.

Getting ink on fingers seemed to be a prerequisite.  Learning was experiential and transmitted - transmitted from those who had gone before.  It seems to me - and I apologise to Networkers who have heard this chant, this plaint before - that our current crop of journalists has only five minute memory and no research skills in spite of having a university degree.  How else to explain the display and promotion of ignorance regarding national affairs that seems to permeate the news stream without correction? How else to explain not being able to see the wood for the trees?  How else to explain the elevation of the unimportant into national catch-cries? And the serious points cast into the darkness of a netherworld never to trouble an intelligence?

'Citizen journalism' can do no more harm than current journalistic standards.  It may well do better.


Besides requiring good memories, hefty diaries, and excellent and deep research skills, I would require a strong community base from the citizen journalist.  Our news is filled with churned out press releases repeating themselves from every quarter - served up to the general public without question and - in many cases - without any alteration.  Journalists go to politicians, corporate and financial players for their 'serious' reporting.  They espouse the cause of celebrity whether it is physically talented sportspeople or vacuous vamps.  Out there in the interaction of real life , community affairs are ignored - except for ambulance, fire engine, and police car chasing.  Oh, I'm sorry. Like the politicians, the journalists are in awe of polls and focus groups and sampling. I must also draw attention to the stentorian  voices of racism, bigotry and populism which promulgate lies and manipulate ignorance.  All this is part of what passes for professional journalism in the second decade of the 21st century.

Some of us can do better than that.


And thank you to the Public Interest Journalism Foundation 
whose latest newsletter contained the link to the article 
which stimulated this rant.



Enhanced by Zemanta

Thursday, 8 December 2011

The Proposed Basin Plan documents and fact sheets. Enough here to make your eyes glaze over!


An ordinary mortal in coming to grips with the material put forward by the Murray Darling Basin Authority (MDBA) in regard to the Proposed Basin Plan is quite a hurdle. I have been remiss in the timeliness of getting these documents to you on line, Networkers.  So.. I hope you have been over at the website.  I have been battling all manner of ill health this past month and this week has been taken up with all manner of medical and allied medical visitations ... and there is a biggy next week.  I am having yet another mammogram but expect this one to enable me to celebrate ten years free of breast cancer!

~~~~~

There is a mountain of material on the MDBA website.  There are the comments from Minister Tony Burke and the Chairman of the Authority, Craig Knowles.  There's a decision to be made about whether one can get to any of the listed consultations.   The consultations appear to be less numerous and widespread than those held by the Authority when the Guide to the Draft Plan last year.  However, I am advised that the current list is only for consultations prior to Christmas.  In the New Year, a new list will appear with more extensive consultations, including Melbourne, on the list. I was able to attend the consultations in Shepparton and in Melbourne last time....but, while the spirit is very willing, the body has got somewhat weaker in the ensuing year.

I did this week attend The Low Down held at Environment Victoria this week.  Lead speaker was the marvellous Juliet Le Feuvre.  She was ably followed by the more than capable Domenica Settle.




These two women are the Rivers Campaigners/Experts for Environment Victoria.
~~~~~~
However, I will begin at the beginning.  The material below is available from the the Authority website.  I download it here, because for some it is more accessible and may prove easier to locate in the longer term.  

I do commend the authority on the document regarding the individual catchments of the Murray Darling Basin.  The individual maps provided are valuable and, I have to wonder, whether teachers might take a good look at the document for classroom use.  In addition, I wonder if localised tourism could be enhanced by marketing catchment tours so people can learn about their rivers, the environment, agriculture, and irrigation.  I have lived in a number of these catchments and have travelled in a number of others.  But what better way to get to know your country than by getting to know the Murray-Darling Basin - people could be encouraged to gather a clutch of catchments in an interlinked regional tourism push.




Basin Plan implementation pathway process


Proposed Basin Plan


Knowledge behind the Plan


The draft Basin Plan: catchment by catchment


The proposed "environmentally sustainable level of take"
for surface water of the Murray-Darling Basin: method and outcomes


Climate change and the Basin Plan


FACT SHEET:
The proposed 'environmentally sustainable level of take'
for surface water of the Murray-Darling Basin


Flooding and the Basin Plan


Hydrological modelling


Managing Australia's water resources


Sustainable diversion limit compliance


Transitional and interim water resource plans


Water Quality and Salinity Management Plan


Communication products for draft Basin Plan release

Delivering a healthy working Basin

Questions answered

Now if you aren't worn out, asleep, or thoroughly bored witless
I won't download any more docs.
HOWEVER,
please go to these linked documents
Supporting Documents
Environmental Watering Plan - What's in it and how will it work?

If it were 1 June, I would suggest gathering the family around the fire for a reading session and you could each take a doc and read snippets to each other over a succession of nights.  This should only take about three months so that on 31 August you can quiz each other and see who passes the comprehension test.  On the first day of Spring collapse in a heap and then hibernate until Christmas.  

Instead it's December. It's hot. Some catchments have had floods already this season and some are keeping an eye on their rivers for more of the same.  The documents have been out for just under a fortnight and there's just over a fortnight until Christmas.  Oh, well. Forget the Christmas Cards.  Give everyone in the family a store gift card.   Who has time to shop?  Merry Christmas and we'll see if we can get this sorted in the New Year.

Wednesday, 8 September 2010

Melbourne Water turns off the North-South Pipeline to make way for water from the Yarra

Sugarloaf Reservoir on Monday 6 September2010
It is 85% full.
To make room for the Yarra River (see post at The Trad Pad)
Melbourne Water has decided to turn off the North-South Pipeline
which brings water from north of the dividing range.
It announced it in this press release issued yesterday.

Community organisations frequently issue press releases.
Few get the publicity they desire -
let alone the action/s they seek.
Congratulations to Jan Beer of Plug the Pipe
for her recent press release
which is posted on The Network here.

One wonders why Melbourne Water had to wait.
They would have known what Jan knew when she knew it,
if not before.
Could it be that they had to seek political permission?
The Brumby Govt has already upset so many people with the pipeline.
Could it really be that they are now concerned
three to four months out from an election?
Or is that they now will really, really look silly
and the pipeline a white elephant?
Related reading:

Friday, 23 October 2009

Participate - Communicate - Agitate



Picture from here

To refuse to participate in the shaping of our future is to give it up ...
Each of us must find our work and do it.
Militancy no longer means guns at high noon, if it ever did.
It means actively working for change,
sometimes in the absence of any surety that change is coming.

from her book Sister Outsider


MissEagle
racism-free
Photobucket

Thursday, 15 October 2009

AND THE GOLD MEDAL GOES TO..........


Gold medal from here.

I don't know what is in the air these days but, if ranting was an Olympic sport, Australia would not only be getting gold medals - it would be breaking world records.

In case you are not clear, dear Networker, on what constitutes a rant here is the definition:

Source: WordNet (r) 1.7
rant

n 1: a loud bombastic declamation expressed with strong emotion

[syn: harangue, ranting]


2: pompous or pretentious talk or writing [syn: bombast, fustian, claptrap, blah]

v : talk in a noisy, excited, or declamatory manner [syn: mouth off, jabber, spout, rabbit on, rave]
So let's get the prize giving over.  
There are three people on the dais.
    Noel Pearson. Picture from here.
Noel Pearson:  His ranting history has been interesting, particularly since he reverted to the Right and decided to vent again the Left.  And it has a literary bent gracing both the Melbourne and Brisbane Writers Festivals and feted by the Griffith Review.

Barnaby Joyce. Picture from here

Barnaby Joyce: The Queensland Senator represents the National Party. This constituency seems to rejoice in people who rant and sound off and do nothing. Barnaby was regarded as open and forthright when he first entered Parliament.  Now, he is the Leader of the National Party in the Senate he seems to think he has to rant for Australia. And there is precious little the National Party can do about anything very much.  Though it is part of a coalition with the Liberal Party, It is a rural rump party with an ever-declining vote.  Queensland is its most significant power base but its glory days seem to be past there and they have now formed themselves into a new party with the Liberals who could not organise themselves outside the southeast corner and Cairns and Townsville. 


Over here pete down south has similar views:

Wed 26 Aug 09 (08:56am) Poor ole Libs (and their hapless apologists, oops I mean supporters). The Nationals are a reinvention of the old DLP. Listening to Joyce rant and spew forth his stupidity makes me wonder what goes through rural Australia’s head. Are the country folk really that stupid?

Rupert Murdoch. Picture from here.

Rupert Murdoch:  Rupert has no difficulty in making his views known.  You don't own as many newspapers and television outlets as Rupert does and so make your views known.  He's not namby-pamby and he does have quite a list of achievements, creditable and discreditable, to his name.  In short, his words are seldom empty.  However, Rupert has qualified and is occupying No. 1 position on the dais because he has taken ranting to new levels.  Firstly, his audience.  Rupert only speaks to somebodies not nobodies.  Secondly, he has taken to name-calling in a B-I-G way.




Here is a sample:

Too often the conventional media response to the internet has been inchoate. A medium once thought too powerful has often seemed impotent in the past few years. Of course there should be a price paid for quality content, and yet large media organizations have been submissive in the face of the flat-earthers who insisted that all content should be free all the time. The sun does not orbit the earth, and yet this was precisely the premise that the press passively accepted, even though there have been obvious signs that readers recognize the reality that they should pay a price.

There are many readers who believe that they are paying for content when they sign up with an internet service provider, presuming that they have bought a ticket to a content buffet. That misconception thrived on the silence of inarticulate institutions which were unable to challenge the fallacies and humbug of the e-establishment.


The value of content has been volatile in the past decade but we are entering another decisive phase in which device makers are again courting the creators of content. I have sensed that shift in recent days during my travels in Japan and South Korea where I met some of the world’s leading electronics manufacturers. These companies don’t want their customers to be served a diet of digital dross, and yet that will be the inevitable consequence if the worth of content and creativity are not appreciated.


The Philistine phase of the digital age is almost over. The aggregators and the plagiarists will soon have to pay a price for the co-opting of our content. But if we do not take advantage of the current movement toward paid-for content, it will be the content creators, the people in this hall, who will pay the ultimate price and the content kleptomaniacs will triumph
And here is what Mark Scott, head of the ABC had to say about Rupert's online plans. 
Addendum 091020: 
Read here about what Mark Scott said before a Senate Committee yesterday. As well as saying:
''Taxpayers have already paid for ABC content and they shouldn't have to pay twice''
Scott explained ABC policy on drama and comedy availability on the internet in relation to DVD sales.
~~~~~~~~~~~


Which brings us to the question of media censorship............


Picture from here.

While Rupert, as head of an Empire, is voicing his complaints there are also people who have their own complaints some of which would be directed at the News Limited empire.  What does the media not give a fair go to?


Project Censored targets the news that doesn't make the news.  Go here for their Top 25 stories.  For alternative media sources, go here.  We could do with an Australian version of Project Censored.  I know the indy media people try but battle against the trials of volunteer resources and so on.
MissEagle
racism-free




Photobucket

Friday, 7 August 2009

TIME FOR A RETHINK JENNY MACKLIN -1

Once upon a long ago, I used to admire Jenny Macklin. During the difficult years of Opposition, Jenny acquitted herself well and managed to take one or two government scalps. I have now come to the conclusion - please give the evidence if I am wrong - she is just so darned insensitive.

Let's just start with the above picture which is the banner on her website. Mmmm....what message is being sent here? What are the semiotics of this picture? Did Jenny think about this?

Let me tell you how I read this and see what you think:
Jenny Macklin - Great White Mother - Under the National Symbol, the Southern Cross - Echoes of Great White Mother of the Nation - Nice Green Tree symbolic of earth and nature (why not a gum tree, Jenny?) - Great White Earth Mother of the Nation.

Great White Earth Mother of the nation, Jenny? Is this how you see yourself? And the children in the photograph. Beautiful kids - but all monoculturally fair. Those who favour an idealised Aryan culture would be pleased. Melbourne, where Jenny's electorate is, prides itself on being strongly multi-cultural. Well, from this picture you would never ever know. Jenny has responsibiity in her portfolio for a lot of Aboriginal kids whom she is purporting to save. Funny how they didn't get a look in.

Jenny's insensitivity extends to her department. The department has been carrying out flawed 'consultation' processes in the Northern Territory for some time. There is a consultative sequence from 1 through to 4. Consultations have been poorly advertised if advertised at all - so that only certain people get to know about them. They are not publicly recorded. CAAMA was actually banned from one of Macklin's meetings. Warlpiri Media had a similar experience and people had to kick up a fuss before they were admitted.

Word came a couple of weeks ago to a Networker from Bagot community in Darwin that a government officer was getting people to sign documents they did not understand. We think what was happening was that a consultation at a certain level was imminent but the previous consultation in the sequence (there is a four-level consultation sequence that has been going on) had not occurred so tracks were being covered.

In short, the consultation process was and is an absolute debacle.

What is happening is that the clock is ticking over. The Rudd Government, a social-democrat government, has been embarrassed on the world stage because it continued the Howard Government's suspension of the Racial Discrimination Act. It plans to re-introduce the act in October. However, there are certain things the government wants to do which would be in breach of the Act. To get around this the government is having consultations and seeking agreement to the things the government wants to do which would be in breach of the Act. Then, once the Act is introduced, and the government is accused of being in breach of the Act, it can then say - but we have the agreement of the Aboriginal people/communities to do these things because they are necessary.

The consultations now and previously have been poorly constituted and handled. Greens Senator Rachel Siewert highlighted this in a Senates Estimates Committee in early June prior to the four stage sequence of consultations. Macklin can't say she wasn't warned. Siewert had the matter nailed and questioned it. Macklin was clearly not sensitive to the import of this question. If she had been, she would have noted that the consultation was being closely monitored. She should have checked that her department had its i's dotted and t's crossed. And it might have helped if she had checked that the department actually knew what an informed and two-way consultative process was.

Now it is time for a rethink, Jenny Macklin, and I have an idea you might like to consider. This is is the subject of the next post.

For further reading:

Friday, 31 July 2009

CABINET IN CONFIDENCE? RELEASE THOSE DAM DOCUMENTS NOW, ANNA BLIGH.

Networker Tanzi
from the Save the Mary Co-ordinating Group
has forwarded the following Press Release:

Save the Mary River Coordinating Group
(STMRCG)
is the group leading the fight
to save the Mary River and Great Sandy Strait
from the damage of the Qld Government's
proposed Traveston Crossing dam.
We have been fighting
this proposal since April 2006

Tony Fitzgerald speaks out on increasing corruption in Queensland government and governance.
***MEDIA RELEASE Thursday July 30th, 2009

"RELEASE THOSE DAM DOCUMENTS NOW, PREMIER!"

Ninety-two percent of respondents to a Courier Mail Poll agree Tony Fitzgerald is right on the money in his scathing criticisms of the Beattie and Bligh governments practices – and the lead group in the fight to prevent the proposed damming of the Mary River at Traveston Crossing agrees with them.

Save the Mary River Coordinating Group President, Glenda Pickersgill said today that the group had experienced frustration and anger at the treatment it had received from the government during the last three years.

She called on the government to immediately release all the “Cabinet in Confidence” documents it had relied on to arrive at the decision to dam the Mary River. “The Beattie/Bligh decision was based purely on political expediency and would be a total waste of billions of taxpayer dollars if it was ever allowed to proceed,” Ms Pickersgill said.

“Let’s get all the information out there for the public to see so they can see what went on. After all, it was paid for by taxpayers” she said.

"It took a 4-day Senate Enquiry in mid -2007 to force the government to reveal some key reports that it had been denying to us. It also made the startling revelation that the desirability of the Traveston Crossing site was based on the briefest of desktop studies, many pages of which were either maps or blank. Many of the reports commissioned since then would appear to be predicated that they must come out in favour of the dam and the site."

"It really does seem that this government's approach is that a well-oiled (and well financed) media department will cover a multitude of shortcomings."

“It would seem that the people of Queensland are now echoing the cry that’s been ringing through the Mary Valley for these last three years, ‘Enough is Enough’.”

END

Contacts for Media: Glenda Pickersgill 0411 443 589. David Kreutz 0432 683 147 Darryl Stewart (Greater Mary Association) 0418 771 655

Website: www.savethemaryriver.com


Monday, 6 July 2009

When I heard the learn'd scientist...and his take on climate change


When I heard the Learn’d Astronomer

When I heard the learn’d astronomer;
When the proofs, the figures, were ranged in columns before me;
When I was shown the charts and the diagrams, to add, divide, and measure them;
When I, sitting, heard the astronomer, where he lectured with much applause in the lecture-room,
How soon, unaccountable, I became tired and sick;
Till rising and gliding out, I wander’d off by myself,
In the mystical moist night-air, and from time to time,
Look’d up in perfect silence at the stars.


I came across this poem to-day and it articulates for me how I feel about all those happy/sad people in community climate change groups around the suburbs of Australia who go around quoting so many parts per million, preaching James Hansen and David Spratt, and muttering Rudd doesn't understand, he doesn't understand.

Now don't get me wrong. I am not a science denier - I am a science listener and I listen to all sorts not just the above mentioned gentlemen. Which is more than a lot of the community activists do. For instance, mention Freeman Dyson to them and eyes pop. Never heard of him - in spite of the fact that he is one of the great intellects of the last century and this. If you pop over here you can hear a Science Show interview with Robyn Williams last year - or read the transcript - with Dyson's interesting take on what needs to be done on climate change: re-foresting the planet. And when did you last here anyone taking to the streets to ask for that?

For me, while the activists are focussing on emission trading schemes and how Copenhagen will turn out, governments across the world are making major decisions which impact adversely NOW on water and food security and yet comparatively little is heard on these issues.

In Australia, this means that phrases such as "qualification of right" and "social water" are entering our language - at least the language of those outside capital cities and major population centres. Developers continue to pay huge money in political donations to political parties and our precious arable land is subsumed by concrete and polluting people. And that is in well-off Australia.

Let's not forget the billions of people who can't afford to buy water from the multi-national corporates like Suez and Veolia and their subsidiaries. Let's not forget the huge numbers of people who forego their own food security in subsistence level agriculture so the World Bank can fund the building of huge dams with dubious long-term benefits. And.....

When the activists eventually get an emission trading scheme to their liking or to the point where there is little use campaigning because the general public are relatively satisfied and stopped listening, there will still be attitudes and behaviour to change that we have not begun to do. Will the community climate change activists be there for the hard yards then? I'm not sure because I don't see their sort of numbers flooding (excuse me please - no pun intended) into water campaigns and food security organisations.

I would be more conducive to the arguments and antics of community climate change activists if their language altered to take into account the person in the street - who CAN understand the idea and practicalities of water scarcity and growing one's own food.

Clearly, I am not the only one who has picked up on the poor communications of the CC activists. Leslie Cannold has summed up the situation well in a recent article. Even to pointing out that the activists do not understand the realities of modern politics.
MissEagle
racism-free

Total Pageviews